LAWYER4EXPATS

Working in Germany

Warning Letter in Germany: What It Means and How to Respond

A warning letter is often the first step towards a dismissal for conduct. How you respond decides whether it can be used against you later.

Facing a dismissal or a termination agreement? An employment lawyer reviews your case for free.Get Your Free Case Review →

A warning letter (Abmahnung) is a formal reprimand from your employer. It says that you breached a duty under your employment contract and that further breaches will lead to a dismissal. In German employment law, it plays a central role: in most cases, an employer cannot dismiss you for your conduct without having warned you first.

That makes a warning letter more than just criticism. It is a building block for a possible dismissal, and it is worth taking seriously, even if it seems unfair or exaggerated.

What a Warning Letter Must Contain

A warning letter is only effective if it fulfils three functions:

  1. Description. It names the specific conduct with date, time and circumstances. General statements such as "you are often late" or "your attitude is poor" are not enough.
  2. Reprimand. It makes clear that the employer considers the conduct a breach of your duties.
  3. Warning. It states that a repeat of similar conduct may lead to a dismissal.

A warning does not have to be in writing, but employers almost always issue it in writing to be able to prove it. It can be issued by anyone who has the right to give you instructions, such as your manager.

If several accusations are combined in one letter and one of them is wrong, the whole warning must be removed from your file. The employer can then issue a new, correct warning for the accusations that are true.

When Is a Warning Required Before a Dismissal?

For a dismissal for your conduct, the employer generally has to warn you first for the same or similar conduct. See dismissal for behavioural reasons. The idea is to give you a chance to change your behaviour.

A warning is not required if the misconduct is so serious that you could not expect the employer to accept it even once, which can be the case with theft, violence or serious fraud. Even then, courts weigh all circumstances, and for minor incidents after many years of good service, a warning may be enough. In serious cases, an extraordinary dismissal can follow directly.

A warning also has a flip side for the employer: it cannot later dismiss you for the very conduct it has already warned you about. Only a new, similar breach can justify a dismissal. Usually one warning is enough before a dismissal. If the employer issues many warnings for the same thing without consequences, a later warning may lose its effect, because it no longer seems serious.

Free Case Review by an Employment Lawyer

An employment lawyer looks at your case and tells you where you stand and what is realistic.

  • Free and non-binding
  • In English
  • Confidential

What Cannot Be the Subject of a Warning

A warning is only possible for conduct you can control. It cannot be issued for:

  • illness itself, although breaches of the duty to report sick or to submit a doctor's note can be warned,
  • lack of ability, if you are trying your best,
  • private conduct outside work, unless it directly affects the employment,
  • exercising your rights, such as claiming overtime pay or contacting the works council.

Your Options

Do nothing. You do not have to respond. If you are later dismissed, you can still argue in court that the warning was unjustified. This is often the most sensible choice if you want to avoid escalation.

Add a written statement. You can give your own account of the facts and have it added to your personnel file. You have a right to this. It is low risk and documents your view.

Demand removal. If the warning is factually wrong or formally defective, you can ask the employer in writing to remove it from your file. If it refuses, you can file a claim at the labour court. If the warning is only formally defective, the employer can issue a corrected one. Once your employment has ended, you usually can no longer demand removal.

Request access to your personnel file. You have a right to see your file and check what has been recorded.

Think carefully before suing over a warning while you are still employed. It can damage the relationship. Get advice on whether it is worth it in your situation.

Received a warning letter, or a dismissal after one? Have both checked before you respond.

Get Your Free Case Review →

How Long a Warning Remains Valid

There is no fixed period after which a warning expires. Its effect fades over time, depending on how serious the breach was and how you have behaved since. Courts reject fixed periods. As a rough rule of thumb from legal literature, minor breaches lose their weight after a few years of good conduct. Some works agreements contain fixed deletion periods.

You can ask for an old warning to be removed from your file once it no longer has any relevance.

Points for Expats

  • Language. A warning in German is valid. Have it translated immediately so you understand exactly what you are accused of.
  • Cultural differences. Rules on punctuality, reporting sick and following instructions are applied strictly in Germany. Ask HR if you are unsure what is expected.
  • First six months and small businesses. During the first six months of employment, whether or not probation was agreed, and in businesses with ten or fewer employees, the employer can dismiss you with notice without a reason, so a warning is not required. A warning is still a clear signal.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to sign the warning letter?

No, there is no obligation to sign, not even to confirm receipt. If you do sign, it only confirms receipt and does not mean you agree with the content. You can add "received, not acknowledged".

Can my employer dismiss me after one warning?

Yes, if you repeat similar misconduct after the warning and the dismissal is otherwise justified.

Does a warning affect my reference?

A single warning usually does not justify a worse reference. The reference must reflect your performance and conduct over the entire employment. See certificate of employment.

Can I be warned by email?

Yes. A warning has no form requirement. Keep a copy for your records.

Describe Your Situation in Under 3 Minutes

Answer a few questions and a lawyer gets in touch with a first assessment. Free, non-binding and confidential.

Start Your Free Case Review
Written byDr. Frank BroerCo-Founder of Legalpaca GmbH, the company behind Lawyer4Expats

Co-founder and managing director of Legalpaca GmbH, which runs Lawyer4Expats. He holds a doctorate in law and passed both German state law exams.

Lawyer4Expats is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. This guide is general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.